The Paradox of Knowing: Part I - The Knowing-Doing Gap

Why Humans Repeat What They Know to Avoid

Why Awareness Rarely Prevents Our Mistakes

Humans are full of contradictions. From the time we are very young, we learn important lessons from our parents, grandparents, teachers, and stories. These are like warnings to help us avoid making the same mistakes others have made. We hear things like, "Be careful, the stove is hot." "Think before you jump." "Don't love someone more than they love you." These wise sayings build up like a shield of knowledge that should logically protect us from getting hurt.

But still, we touch the hot stove. We jump without looking first. We give our whole hearts to people who don't feel the same way about us.

This difference between what we know and what we actually do is one of the most confusing things about being human. We understand that one thing causes another. We can often guess what will happen next. We see the results of certain choices in other people's lives and promise ourselves we'll choose differently. Yet, we still go down paths that we know are bad for us, especially in our close relationships.

What explains this strange disconnect? Why doesn't knowing something usually lead to us changing our behavior? The answer has to do with how our brains work, what we need emotionally, and what it means to be human.

Maybe just knowing something isn't enough. Perhaps there's a big difference between understanding something in our minds and truly learning it through experience. Our logical brains might plan the safest way to go, but our feelings and unconscious desires often guide our actions.

This essay will look at the space between knowing and doing. We'll explore why the connection between them often breaks down and what this ongoing gap tells us about being human. By looking at the forces that separate what we know from what we do, we might start to understand why so much wisdom from the past hasn't stopped us from making mistakes that feel both expected and unavoidable.

Because when we understand why we contradict ourselves, we might feel not just annoyed at our weaknesses, but also kinder towards the complicated nature of being human.

The Illusion of Thinking Things Through

We like to think of ourselves as logical people. Way back, the ancient Greeks praised humans as the "rational animal." For a long time, many thinkers in the Western world have seen reason as what makes us special. We create detailed stories about how we make decisions, telling ourselves that our choices come from thinking things through carefully and using logic.

But this idea we have about ourselves, while it feels good, is often not the full picture. It's more like we're explaining after we've made a choice, rather than describing how we really made it.

Thinking Fast and Slow

Experts who study how people behave economically and how our minds work have shown that the idea of people always acting purely logically isn't quite right.

Someone famous for this research, Daniel Kahneman, showed that our decisions come from two ways of thinking:

1. A fast, gut-feeling system that uses emotions and works automatically without you even trying.

2. A slower system that thinks things through, which is what we usually mean by our "thinking self."

We might think our conscious, thinking mind is in charge. But research shows that our gut-feeling system often decides before our logical mind even gets involved. Our conscious thinking is often just used to explain or defend choices we already made based on feelings or intuition. If you've ever wondered how humans make decisions, this two-system idea is key.

Why We Ignore Warning Signs

Think about relationships again. Maybe you've seen friends get their hearts broken because they didn't pay attention to clear warning signs. Or maybe it's happened to you. You make a list of these "red flags" and promise you'll never ignore them again.

But then you meet someone you're really attracted to. Suddenly, all those lessons you learned seem to disappear. You find yourself coming up with clever reasons for why this situation is different and why this person is the exception to the patterns you recognized before.

"I know they seem emotionally unavailable, but they're just going through a tough time right now."

"They haven't wanted a serious relationship before, but they've never met anyone who truly understands them like I do."

"Yeah, we have some major differences, but doesn't that make things more interesting?"

These excuses aren't reason winning out. They show that our logic is actually following our emotions. Our logical mind becomes like a public relations person, whose job is to create believable excuses for choices made by stronger forces inside us that we're less aware of. People often search for why people ignore red flags, and this is a big part of the answer.

The Power of Feelings in Big Choices

This trick our mind plays works especially well when our feelings are deeply involved. Relationships, with their strong mix of needing connection, ideas from movies and stories, and the feel-good chemicals in our brain, create the perfect situation for our logical mind to get pushed aside while we still feel like we're in control. This shows the powerful link between logic and emotion.

Understanding this doesn't mean you'll never fall into this trap. But it can help you be a bit more humble about how you make choices. Maybe true wisdom starts not with just assuming we're always logical, but with realizing how rarely we actually make decisions based purely on reason – especially when it comes to important emotional things.

Are We Really That Logical? The Myth of Rational Choices

Have you ever wondered why we do things that don't make sense, even when we know better? We often think we make decisions based on facts and logic. But what if something else is really in charge?

Often, our choices are guided by something called emotional reasoning. This is when your feelings, not facts, become the main reason for what you do.

How Emotional Reasoning Works

Emotional reasoning follows a simple rule: "If I feel it strongly, it must be true."

It skips the step where you stop and think carefully. Instead, it takes your feelings and makes them seem like solid facts. You usually don't even notice this is happening! It feels completely natural.

Why Feelings Are So Powerful

Our emotional brain is much older than the part of our brain that handles complex thinking. These older brain parts react very quickly to danger or opportunity. Logic just can't keep up.

When we're in situations that involve important emotional needs – like needing to feel loved, accepted, or close to someone – these brain systems take over. They can feel incredibly strong.

Feelings vs. Facts in Relationships

Think about dating or relationships. Your brain might know things like:

• What someone did before often shows what they'll do later.

• People usually don't completely change their main personality traits.

• Relationships where you always have to give things up often lead to feeling angry later.

• How people talked to each other at the start often stays the same.

But when emotional reasoning kicks in, these smart ideas become quiet whispers. They get lost behind the loud voice of your feelings. The feeling you have right now – maybe you're excited about new love, scared of being alone, or feel safe with someone even if they cause you pain – can feel more real and important than all the smart things you know.

Why do feelings control decisions, especially in love? Science helps explain this. When you're feeling strong emotions, more blood goes to the parts of your brain linked to feelings. Less blood goes to the part responsible for clear thinking and making smart choices.

Basically, strong feelings can actually make it harder to think clearly, right when you need to the most! This is even stronger when you add the powerful brain chemicals linked to liking someone and feeling connected.

Signs You're Using Emotional Reasoning

You can spot emotional reasoning in certain thoughts:

• "I feel unsure about this relationship. So, my partner must be someone I can't trust."

• "This connection feels amazing! So, the problems that ended my past relationships won't happen this time."

• "I feel complete when I'm with this person. So, they must be 'the one,' even if we aren't really right for each other."

These kinds of thoughts ignore a lot of proof, your own experiences, and what you've learned. You might ignore patterns you've seen many times because this situation feels different, even if it's actually similar to bad situations you've been in before.

The Emotional Reasoning Loop

Here's the tricky part: emotional reasoning can create a cycle. Your feelings shape how you see things. How you see things then creates more feelings that agree with your first feeling.

Let's say your partner makes a simple comment. If you're feeling a bit unsure, that comment might seem like clear proof they don't care enough. This makes you feel more unsure, which continues the cycle. This is how emotional reasoning can lead you away from what's actually happening. People often search for how emotions affect choices and this loop is a big part of it.

Finding a Balance

This doesn't mean your emotions are always wrong. Feelings often give us important information that simple logic misses. But when feelings completely take over and ignore what you know intellectually, you're more likely to repeat mistakes you wish you wouldn't.

Understanding logic vs emotion in relationships and realizing the power of emotional reasoning doesn't mean you'll stop feeling things. But it might give you a moment to pause. It offers a brief chance to notice when you're letting feelings stand in for facts. In that moment of noticing, you can perhaps take back some control over the choices that shape your life. Learning how to stop making decisions based on emotions starts with recognizing this process.

Why We Repeat Relationship Mistakes: Real Examples

Have you ever noticed how some people seem to end up in the same kind of relationship trouble, even with different partners? Nowhere is the gap between knowing something and actually doing something about it clearer than in our love lives. Many of us go through relationships almost like actors in a play we didn't choose, repeating the same basic story with new people, but getting similar unhappy results. Even when we really want to change and have learned lessons, we often find ourselves drawn to the same old patterns – even if they hurt us before. People often ask, "Why do I repeat relationship mistakes?" These examples might help explain.

Why We're Pulled Towards What's Familiar

One major reason we repeat patterns is that we're unconsciously attracted to what feels known or familiar. Our first experiences with important people as kids shape how we expect relationships to work. These early times create paths in our brains that feel like "home," even if "home" meant feeling unsure, never knowing what to expect, or having people who weren't emotionally there for us.

Look at the common situation of someone who keeps chasing partners who aren't emotionally available.

• Sarah's Story: Sarah's dad was often distant and you never knew if he'd pay attention to her. As an adult, she knew intellectually she was often attracted to men who were emotionally unavailable. Her friends pointed it out. Therapists helped her understand why she did this. She could perfectly explain why these relationships were bad for her and how they were just like her childhood experiences.

But just knowing wasn't enough to break relationship patterns. When she met new guys, she felt a strong, hard-to-explain connection only with those who seemed a bit distant emotionally. Guys who were steady and paid attention? She found them boring. Her thinking mind wanted a stable relationship, but her emotional brain recognized the old pattern of chasing someone distant as feeling like "love." This is a classic example of the attraction to unavailable partners.

The Pull to Repeat the Past

There's also an idea called "repetition compulsion" from psychology. It suggests we sometimes repeat painful situations without realizing it, hoping to finally get it right or feel in control this time. From this point of view, we repeat relationship patterns because of past pain, not despite it. We're driven by an unconscious need to change our emotional past.

• Michael's Story: After a really bad relationship, Michael promised himself he'd never date someone jealous and controlling again. But he kept finding himself drawn to similar types of people. Each time, he truly believed this relationship would be different because he felt he "knew better" now. But the same problems always came up. This wasn't because he was dumb, but because he had an unconscious hope that this time, he could fix things – that he could finally feel trusted and secure in a way he hadn't as a child or in past relationships.

What Brain Chemistry Does

Our brain chemistry also makes it harder to use our relationship knowledge. The mix of chemicals when we're attracted to someone – like dopamine and oxytocin – can feel a lot like addiction. Research even shows that when relationships are uncertain, with ups and downs, it can make these chemical responses stronger. This is why people talk about love addiction.

• Lisa's Story: Lisa understood this logically. She'd read studies about how getting rewards sometimes (but not always) makes you more hooked than getting them all the time. She saw how the unpredictable highs and lows of her on-again, off-again relationship felt like a gambling addiction to her brain. But knowing this couldn't beat the powerful chemical pull that made stable, calm options seem dull.

The Influence of Love Stories

The stories we hear growing up and in movies also make it tough to apply what we know. Stories about love changing a difficult person, about sticking with someone despite everything, or about big fights leading to lasting happiness – these ideas are everywhere, from fairy tales to romantic comedies.

These stories offer something logic doesn't: hope. They suggest that repeating mistakes isn't a failure, but just part of the journey to a happy ending. Even when we know these stories aren't usually real life, how they make us feel can seem more important than what we know intellectually.

It's Hard to See It When You're In It

Maybe the hardest part is that we can't easily see these patterns when we're actually in a new relationship. We can clearly spot our friends' relationship patterns. We can even see our own, after they're over. But when we're newly attracted to someone, it's much harder to recognize the pattern happening again. People struggle with ignoring relationship red flags in the moment.

We tell ourselves that small differences mean big change: "My last partners were always broke, but this one has a good job" (while ignoring that this new person is just as emotionally unavailable as the others). Or we focus on how much we've learned: "I know what I'm getting into this time" (as if simply knowing could change the outcome). This is why learning from past relationships is harder than it seems.

These stories show a difficult truth: simply understanding why we repeat relationship patterns, while necessary to change, is often not enough on its own. The gap between knowing and doing exists because relationship patterns aren't just puzzles for our brain. They're complicated results of unconscious needs, brain chemistry, cultural ideas, and emotional reasoning – all working below the surface while we think we're making logical choices.

Hope and Optimism: Why They Can Lead Us to Repeat Mistakes

If just knowing about our past mistakes doesn't stop us from repeating them, and if we only see our patterns clearly after things go wrong, what's powerful enough to make us ignore what we've already lived through? The answer involves two very human things: hope and optimism. These two qualities, which are important for bouncing back from tough times, strangely also help explain why we keep making the same known mistakes. This helps answer why hope makes you repeat mistakes.

Why Hope Is Important (and Tricky)

Hope isn't just a nice feeling. It's actually a survival tool built into our brains. For humans throughout history, those who kept hoping when things were hard were more likely to keep trying and survive. This is how our ancestors kept hunting even after many failed tries, planted crops again after bad harvests, or made new friends after being let down.

In relationships, this same tool turns on when we face situations that remind us of past hurts. Instead of seeing past experiences as clear proof of what might happen, our minds create pictures of different futures. We imagine possibilities where similar situations turn out well this time. This ability to picture better futures is vital for human progress, but it becomes risky when it makes us ignore clear evidence from the past.

Thinking "This Time Is Different"

Along with hope comes something psychologists call the "uniqueness bias." This is our tendency to see our own situations as special or different. While we can easily spot patterns in our friends' lives, we look at our own through a lens that says, "This is my situation, it's happening now." The present feels so real and immediate that memories of the past feel less vivid.

• "Yes, intense relationships often end quickly, but what we have is different."

• "I know I tend to attract emotionally unavailable people, but this person is unavailable only because of their job, not because they're like that deep down."

• "The facts about long-distance relationships don't apply to us because our connection is so uniquely strong."

This feeling that "this time is different" happens without us even realizing it. It lets us agree that patterns exist in general, but tell ourselves our current situation is an exception. It means we have knowledge, but we don't always use it where it matters most.

Falling for Potential

Maybe the most powerful part of hope in dating is that we're often attracted not to people as they are right now, but to who they could be. We fall for potential. We see glimpses of good qualities that might grow, connections that could get deeper, or the person our partner might become if our love changes them. This is often called falling for potential vs. reality.

Focusing on who someone could be instead of who they are lets us ignore things that don't fit the story we want. Early relationship red flags can seem like challenges to overcome or chances for future growth. The gap between the way things are now and the way we imagine they'll be later seems smaller in our minds, making unlikely happy endings feel almost guaranteed.

This focus on potential is a strong force that can override what we know. Even when we understand intellectually that people rarely change their core personality or behavior, hope convinces us that our situation will be the rare case. The imagined future has more power over our choices than all the lessons from our past experiences.

Optimism as a Filter

Optimism acts like a filter for information in our brains. It helps us see things in a way that keeps our positive expectations strong, even if past experiences tell us otherwise. Research shows that optimistic people tend to:

• Blame bad experiences on outside, temporary things, while seeing good experiences as being because of who they are and likely to last.

• Remember positive things more easily than negative ones.

• Think of more positive ways to understand unclear situations.

• Downplay how relevant negative past experiences are when guessing what will happen in the future.

These ways of thinking, while helpful for feeling good generally, create blind spots. They stop us from using the hard-earned lessons from our past. Our optimistic filter highlights all the reasons why things will be different this time, while downplaying anything that suggests we might repeat painful patterns. People often search about optimism bias in relationships.

The Power of Now vs. Later

Another reason hope overrides experience is something called "temporal discounting." This means we tend to value how we feel right now more than what might happen later. The strong, immediate feelings of a new connection are real and powerful. They can easily overpower the abstract knowledge we have about possible future pain.

When you're caught up in the exciting feeling of new romance, warnings from past experiences feel distant and easy to ignore. The intense reality of how you feel now simply feels more important than the idea of future regret. This creates a situation where you can intellectually know something while acting against it. This is related to the difference between present vs future feelings.

The Main Puzzle

Here's the main puzzle: the very things that make humans strong and able to bounce back – hope, optimism, being able to picture better futures even after tough times – also make it more likely that we'll repeat patterns we know are bad for us. The qualities that make us uniquely human and help us move forward also make us vulnerable to making the same mistakes.

Maybe being wise isn't about getting rid of hope (which is impossible and probably not good anyway). Instead, it's about having a different kind of relationship with it. Maybe we need hope that's balanced by experience, and optimism that understands patterns. That might let us keep our human ability to dream of better futures while being less likely to repeat painful histories.

How to Stop Repeating Relationship Mistakes: Putting What You Know into Action

Understanding why it's hard to act on what you know is helpful. But the big question is: Can we actually get better at it? While you probably can't completely control all your deep-down feelings and instincts, there are ways to use your smarts more effectively in your emotional life. Learning how to break relationship patterns is possible.

Pay Attention to Your Body

Simply knowing things intellectually doesn't often change what you do, because your emotions and body reactions sometimes act separately from your thinking mind. Embodied awareness means paying attention to how your emotions feel physically. This creates an important link between knowing and doing.

Try to notice what your body feels like when you have certain emotions linked to your past patterns. Maybe it's a tight feeling in your chest when you meet someone who reminds you of old hurts. Maybe it's that fluttery, excited feeling that has led to bad choices before. Or the specific way attraction feels right before you get into a relationship that ends up being painful like past ones. These body signals often show up before you even start consciously thinking, acting like early warnings that a pattern might be starting again. Learning to listen to your body emotions gives you a heads-up.

By getting better at noticing these physical signs, you create a chance to make a choice. There's a brief moment between feeling something and reacting to it where you could do things differently. This doesn't mean you won't have emotional reactions, but it gives you space to choose how you respond.

Write Down Your Patterns

Our minds are good at remembering certain things and forgetting others, especially when emotions are strong. Writing down your patterns creates a record outside your head that's less likely to change based on how you're currently feeling.

After a relationship doesn't work out, write down details about how it happened. What early warning signs did you see but ignore? What excuses did you make for their behavior (or yours)? Were there moments when you saw things clearly, but pushed that knowledge away? Review these notes when you start seeing someone new. Don't use them to be negative, but as tools to look honestly at the situation.

Some people find it helpful to make an actual relationship patterns checklist for themselves and look at it when making decisions about a new person. This written knowledge is harder for hope to twist and override your inner knowing.

Get Advice from Wise Friends

It's often easy to see patterns in other people's lives, but hard to see our own. Find friends who seem to make good choices in relationships and who care enough about you to be honest, even if it's hard to hear. Give them clear permission to point out if they see you repeating old patterns.

Choosing the right friends is important. Pick people who can really see situations clearly, not just friends who will agree with whatever you say. Their view from the outside can provide clarity when your own feelings are making things cloudy.

Take Things Slowly

Many relationship mistakes happen because strong feelings and hope make things move too fast before you can see patterns clearly. Deliberately slowing down a new relationship gives you time to think things through, both consciously and unconsciously.

This might mean setting your own rules about how quickly you get physically intimate, as physical closeness can release powerful bonding chemicals that make it harder to think logically. It might mean keeping up your own hobbies and friendships instead of quickly spending all your time together. These boundaries create space to see how things are developing more clearly.

Question Your Stories

We often ignore what we know by telling ourselves stories about why this situation is special and different from past patterns. Get into the habit of directly questioning these stories:

• When you think, "This person is different," ask yourself specifically how their actions (not just the situation or how you feel) show this difference.

• When you feel, "This time will be different because I've changed," think about real proof. How has your new awareness led to you making different choices, not just having different thoughts?

• When you believe, "Our connection is unique," remember that every relationship feels unique when you're in it, but they often follow recognizable patterns from the outside.

This kind of questioning your thoughts creates a pause in the automatic way we override knowledge, making it harder to dismiss what you've learned.

Expect Small Steps, Not Big Leaps

Maybe the most realistic way to bridge this gap is to understand that it rarely happens with a sudden, huge change. More often, you get better little by little. This means having relationships that are perhaps still not perfect, but have slightly healthier patterns than the ones before.

Instead of expecting to suddenly be perfect at applying your relationship wisdom, look for signs that your patterns are slowly getting better. Did this relationship last a bit longer before old problems showed up? Are you noticing patterns earlier? Is the intensity of the negative cycles decreasing? These small improvements, even if they don't feel as dramatic as completely breaking a pattern, are real progress in linking what you know with what you do.

Bringing Head and Heart Together

In the end, bridging the gap between knowing and doing isn't about your brain winning over your emotions, or your emotions completely taking over. It's about putting your thinking and feeling sides together. This doesn't mean you'll make perfect choices every time, but it helps what you know match up better with what you do.

Practices like mindfulness for relationships are really helpful here. By simply observing your thoughts, feelings, and body sensations without immediately judging them or reacting, you build the ability to see things from different angles at once. You can honor both how you feel emotionally and what you understand intellectually, without letting one completely drown out the other.

This joining of head and heart isn't about never making mistakes again. It's about having a more aware relationship with your choices, even the imperfect ones. They come from a fuller understanding of the many forces shaping them. People looking for how to stop repeating dating mistakes can benefit from these strategies.

It's Okay to Be Human: Learning and Growing

The difference between knowing what you should do and actually doing it is something that's always been a part of being human. We've talked about how thinking we're always logical isn't totally true, how feelings often win over facts, how relationship patterns repeat even when we see them, how hope and optimism can make us ignore warnings, and how we can try to connect our knowing and doing sides better. But even with all this understanding and all these strategies, we're still going to make mistakes. Sometimes, we'll still do things that go against what we know is best.

This makes you wonder: What if the gap between knowing and doing isn't just a problem to fix? What if it's just a basic part of being human? What if being perfectly consistent between what you know and what you do isn't a goal you can completely reach, but more like a direction that guides your growth, always a little out of perfect reach? This is part of why change is hard.

Being Kind to Yourself

Maybe the best way to handle this knowing-doing gap is to simply accept that we have limits as humans, and to be kind about it. We are really complex beings. We can think logically about complicated ideas, but we're also deeply affected by our emotions and what our bodies feel. The struggle between these different parts of us causes some of our biggest problems, but also leads to our greatest growth.

When we make mistakes that we knew how to avoid, it's easy to be really hard on ourselves. But judging yourself harshly usually makes the knowing-doing gap bigger, not smaller. It makes you defensive and pushes your thinking and feeling sides further apart. Being kind – to yourself and to others who are stuck in similar patterns – creates a space where real learning and connecting can happen. It's about self-compassion.

This kindness isn't just giving up. It's actively accepting that our human nature is complex. It recognizes that perfect consistency between knowing and doing might be too much to ask, not because we're bad or not good enough, but because we are amazing, complicated beings living in a complicated world.

Finding Value in Mistakes

Looking at our repeated mistakes differently, they show us something important about how humans learn. Maybe some understanding can't just be taught intellectually; maybe it has to be felt and lived through experience. Maybe some lessons need you to live them, sometimes more than once, before they change from just an idea in your head to something you truly understand deep down.

From this point of view, the mistakes we make even when we know better aren't just failures. They're necessary steps in a deeper learning process. They aren't a sign that wisdom has failed, but that wisdom is developing – moving from an abstract idea to a lived truth. This is part of your personal growth journey.

Growth Means Connecting, Not Being Perfect

If we accept that the knowing-doing gap might never fully disappear, then maybe growth isn't about being perfectly consistent between knowledge and action. Instead, it's about getting better and better at connecting our thinking, feeling, and physical selves. This connection doesn't mean you'll always make the right choice, but it helps you be more aware of what's influencing your decisions and feel more actively involved in making them.

This kind of growth doesn't look like never repeating mistakes. It looks like spotting patterns sooner, recovering faster when things go wrong, and learning more deeply from each time it happens. It's about being more flexible, not rigidly perfect. It's the ability to hold your intellectual knowledge alongside your emotional needs with curiosity, not judgment.

The Human Story

In the end, the knowing-doing gap reminds us of what we fundamentally are – beings who are always changing, not just logical or just emotional, but complex mixes of many ways of knowing and being. Our contradictions don't mean we're failures. They show that we are truly human, taking part in the lifelong process of becoming more fully ourselves.

Maybe wisdom is not about trying to escape this part of us, but about accepting it. It's about humbly admitting the constant difference between what we know and what we do, while still trying to lessen that gap through conscious effort and kind practice. In this ongoing dance between knowing and doing, we find not just the limits of being human, but its incredible beauty and potential.

Because it's exactly in that space between what we know and what we do – in our messy, imperfect tries to get them to line up – that we discover what it truly means to be human. It's about mindfulness and self-compassion on that path.

---